Solid State Relays | Electromechanical Relays | |
Noise | No Noise | Noise due to contact switching |
EMI | No EMI as no switching is involved | EMI due to arcing during switching |
Zero Voltage switching | Possible | Not Possible |
Resistance to shock | They are resistant to shock and vibration | These relays can be affected by shock and vibration. |
Temperature sensitivity | Sensitive to Temperature | less sensitive to temperature |
Heat Generation | Heat is generated due to higher resistance | Low resistance in the contacts. Hence, less heat is produced |
Heat dissipation | Heat Sink is required | Heat sink is not required. |
Leakage Current | Solid State Relays do not completely turn off. There is a slight leakage Current. This can affect downstream circuits. | No leakage current. The relays can be completely switched on or off. |
Lifetime | very long lifetimes. | Relatively short lifetime |
Solid State Auxiliary Relays and Electromechanical Auxiliary Relays-A comparison
Tags
electromechanical,
optocoupler,
relay,
relays,
solid state